Can You Win an Arizona DUI Refusal Hearing?

A Recent Tucson Admin Per Se Victory

If you were arrested for DUI in Tucson and accused of refusing a blood or breath test, you may have been told that losing your driver's license is automatic.

It is not.

Arizona's implied consent law gives the Motor Vehicle Division significant power to suspend a person's driving privilege after an alleged refusal—but the government still has to prove specific facts before that suspension can be upheld.

I recently represented a client in an Arizona Admin Per Se refusal hearing where the hearing officer ruled in my client's favor before I even had an opportunity to cross-examine the State's witness.

That result is a good reminder of something I tell DUI clients all the time: an administrative license hearing is not a formality. The evidence matters. The witnesses matter. And sometimes what is missing from the State's case matters just as much as what is there.

What Is an Admin Per Se Hearing in Arizona?

After a DUI arrest, there may be two separate cases moving forward.

The first is the criminal DUI case, which may be filed in Tucson City Court, Pima County Justice Court, or another Arizona court depending on where the arrest occurred.

The second is an administrative driver's license case involving the Arizona Department of Transportation Motor Vehicle Division.

These are separate proceedings.

Under Arizona's implied consent law, A.R.S. § 28-1321, a person who operates a motor vehicle in Arizona is generally deemed to have consented to certain testing for alcohol or drugs after a qualifying DUI arrest. If the government alleges that the driver refused the requested test, MVD may seek a driver's license suspension.

For a first refusal, the potential suspension is generally 12 months. A second or subsequent refusal within the statutory period can result in a two-year suspension. Arizona law also provides a limited period in which the driver can request an administrative hearing; currently, the hearing request generally must be received within 30 days of the notice or suspension order. A timely hearing request ordinarily stays the suspension until the hearing is held. 

That deadline is one reason it is important to contact an Arizona DUI attorney quickly after an arrest.

What Does the Government Have to Prove at a Refusal Hearing?

An Arizona refusal hearing is much narrower than a DUI trial.

Under A.R.S. § 28-1321(K), the hearing addresses only whether:

  1. A law enforcement officer had reasonable grounds to believe the person was driving or in actual physical control while under the influence;

  2. The person was placed under arrest;

  3. The person refused the designated test; and

  4. The person was informed of the consequences of refusal. 

That may sound simple. In practice, each element can raise factual questions.

Who actually saw the driving?

Which officer made the observations suggesting impairment?

Who administered field sobriety tests?

Who administered or observed a preliminary breath test?

What information did the arresting officer actually have?

What was the driver told about the consequences of refusing?

And, importantly, can the witness who appears at the hearing actually establish those facts?

A Recent Tucson-Area Refusal Hearing

In my recent case, the State called a law enforcement officer who had responded to the DUI investigation after the traffic stop was already underway.

The officer had some personal observations. He recalled seeing watery eyes and smelling a moderate odor of intoxicants. He had also been shown a preliminary breath test result.

But there were important limitations to what he actually knew.

He had not personally observed my client driving.

He had not observed the alleged traffic violation.

He did not remember being told why the vehicle had originally been stopped.

He had not administered the preliminary breath test and had not watched my client provide the sample. At the hearing, he could not independently remember the specific numerical PBT result—only that he remembered it being above .08.

Those distinctions matter.

The officer who had made the initial observations and conducted significant portions of the DUI investigation did not testify.

Before I even began my cross-examination, the hearing officer ruled in my client's favor.

The suspension was not sustained.

But Isn't Hearsay Allowed in an MVD Hearing?

Yes.

This is one of the important differences between an Arizona administrative license hearing and a criminal trial.

Administrative hearings are not governed by the same strict evidentiary rules that apply in criminal court. A hearing officer may consider hearsay evidence, including information one officer received from another.

But that does not mean every piece of hearsay automatically deserves the same weight as reliable firsthand evidence.

There is still an important question:

How reliable is the information being offered?

That became particularly significant in this case because the underlying DUI investigation itself contained issues that the missing investigating officer would have been in the best position to explain.

For example, the investigation involved a deputy who was conducting his first DUI investigation while working with a more experienced training officer. The body-worn camera showed the officers discussing observations and field sobriety test scoring as the investigation developed.

There were also inconsistencies in the documentation concerning how many cues had supposedly been observed on one of the field sobriety tests.

Those are exactly the kinds of details that make witness preparation and evidence review important.

A police report may make an investigation sound linear and certain.

Body-worn camera sometimes tells a more complicated story.

Why Reviewing Body-Worn Camera Matters in a Tucson DUI Case

DUI cases often involve conclusions such as:

  • "Slurred speech"

  • "Watery or bloodshot eyes"

  • "Poor balance"

  • "Failed field sobriety tests"

  • "Changed story"

  • "Refused testing"

Those phrases can look damaging when they appear in a police report.

But as a Tucson DUI defense attorney, I want to know how the officer reached those conclusions.

Did the officer personally observe the symptom?

Did another officer point it out?

Was a field sobriety test independently scored, or did officers discuss the scoring afterward?

Does the body-worn camera actually show what the report describes?

Did the driver follow most instructions correctly even though the report emphasizes mistakes?

Did an officer who later wrote a definitive report sound less certain while the investigation was actually happening?

None of those questions automatically wins a DUI case.

But they can change how the evidence should be evaluated.

A PBT Is Not the Same as a DUI Blood or Breath Test

Another common source of confusion is the preliminary breath test, sometimes called a PBT.

A roadside PBT is often used during the DUI investigation. It is different from the formal evidentiary breath, blood, or urine testing that may follow an arrest.

In this hearing, the officer who testified had not administered the PBT and had not watched it being administered. He remembered being shown the result afterward.

That distinction was important because the hearing was about what the State could actually establish through the evidence presented—not simply what numbers appeared somewhere in a report.

This is why a DUI defense should not begin and end with, "The police report says the PBT was over .08."

The surrounding evidence matters.

What If You Actually Refused the Blood Test?

Do not assume there is nothing an attorney can do.

A refusal case requires its own analysis.

Arizona law requires the State to establish not only a refusal but also that the motorist was informed of the consequences of refusing. A.R.S. § 28-1321 specifically identifies that advisement as an issue at the administrative hearing. 

Depending on the facts, a DUI attorney may examine:

  • What test the officer requested;

  • Exactly what the driver said or did;

  • Whether the response was actually an unequivocal refusal;

  • Whether the officer correctly explained the consequences;

  • Whether there was confusion during the advisement;

  • Whether the officer later obtained a search warrant;

  • What the body-worn camera shows; and

  • Whether the witnesses who appear at the hearing can reliably establish the necessary elements.

Refusal hearings are difficult. Winning one is never guaranteed.

But "difficult" and "automatic" are not the same thing.

Why Requesting the MVD Hearing Can Matter Even Beyond Your License

An administrative hearing can also give a DUI defense lawyer an early opportunity to examine the investigation.

The officer may testify under oath about:

  • The traffic stop;

  • Signs of alleged impairment;

  • Field sobriety tests;

  • Preliminary breath testing;

  • The arrest decision;

  • The implied consent advisement; and

  • The alleged refusal.

That testimony may matter later when evaluating the criminal DUI case.

An officer who gives one explanation at an administrative hearing and a different explanation months later in criminal court may create an important credibility issue.

For that reason, I frequently view an Admin Per Se hearing as more than simply a driver's license proceeding. It can be an important part of developing the overall DUI defense.

Arrested for DUI in Tucson? Do Not Ignore the MVD Side of the Case

If you have been arrested for DUI in Tucson, Pima County, Oro Valley, Marana, Sahuarita, Green Valley, or elsewhere in Southern Arizona, pay attention to every document involving your driver's license.

The deadline to request a hearing can come much sooner than the resolution of the criminal case.

And do not assume that because an officer says you "refused," a license suspension is inevitable.

The first questions should be:

What actually happened? What does the body-worn camera show? Who observed it? And can the government prove what it says happened?

Those were important questions in this recent case, and my client walked out of the administrative process without the refusal suspension being sustained.

Every case is different, and past results do not guarantee a similar outcome. But every DUI case deserves an individualized review of the evidence rather than an assumption that the police report tells the entire story.

If you were arrested for DUI in Tucson and received an Arizona Admin Per Se or implied consent suspension notice, contact AJB Law Firm as soon as possible. We can review the arrest, determine the applicable MVD deadline, evaluate whether a hearing should be requested, and begin examining the evidence in both the driver's license and criminal cases.

Frequently Asked Questions About Arizona DUI Refusal Hearings

How long do I have to request an Arizona MVD refusal hearing?
Arizona law generally requires the hearing request to be received within 30 days of the applicable notice or suspension order. 

Does requesting a hearing stop my suspension?
A timely hearing request generally stays the refusal suspension until the administrative hearing is held. 

Can I win an Admin Per Se refusal hearing?
Yes, it is possible. The State must establish the statutory elements, and the result depends on the evidence in the individual case.

Does winning the MVD hearing dismiss my DUI charge?
No. The administrative license case and criminal DUI prosecution are separate proceedings. Arizona law expressly provides that a decision not to sustain the administrative suspension does not control the criminal proceeding. 

Should I hire a Tucson DUI lawyer before requesting the hearing?
Because the deadline is short and the administrative hearing can affect both your driving privilege and the development of your DUI defense, it is worth speaking with an attorney promptly.

Next
Next

What Happens at an Arraignment in Tucson and Pima County?